The legal conflict stems from a November 2025 appearance by Haley Kalil on Marlon Garcias Mar Athon Twitch livestream. During the broadcast, Haley discussed the 2022 end of her seven year marriage to Matt Kalil, citing extreme physical incompatibility as the primary reason. She graphically compared Matts genitalia to two Coke cans stacked together, maybe even a third, and stated that the size made their physical relationship nearly impossible and left her in tears. These comments quickly went viral, generating millions of views across TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube.

Claims of Privacy Invasion and Unjust Enrichment

In court documents obtained on January 7, 2026, Matt Kalil alleges that Haley disclosed highly intimate and private facts that have caused him significant public humiliation. The lawsuit asserts that these remarks were degrading and deeply personal, destroying his ability to maintain a private life following his retirement from the NFL. Furthermore, the suit includes a claim for unjust enrichment, arguing that Haley purposefully used these sensational claims to increase her viewership, engagement, and monetization across her social media platforms, which boast over 25 million combined followers.

Impact on Matts New Marriage and Family

A significant portion of the lawsuit focuses on the collateral damage caused to Matts current family. Since the clip went viral, his current wife, Keilani Asmus, whom he married in 2024, has reportedly been subjected to a barrage of disturbing and alarming messages from the public. Matt claims that the ongoing circulation of these statements has created a hostile environment for his family, turning his private medical and physical attributes into a subject of invasive public commentary and mockery.

Damages and Haleys Response

Matt Kalil is seeking a jury trial and damages in excess of $75,000. Legal experts suggest the amount could rise significantly if the court finds that Haleys financial gain from the viral content was substantial. For her part, Haley expressed shock and hurt over the filing. In a statement to media outlets, she maintained that she spoke highly of Matt throughout the original livestream and viewed her life story as a comedy. However, the lawsuit suggests that for Matt, the joke has gone too far.